Mustard Magic: Unveiling the 7 Best Mustard Varieties for Brats in 2024

7 Best Mustard for Brats of 2024

Bratwurst sausages are known for their delicious flavor, and one condiment that complements them perfectly is mustard. However, choosing the right mustard for brats can be a daunting task, as the wrong choice can ruin the entire bratwurst experience. In this article, we will explore the best mustards for brats in 2023, taking into account factors such as flavor, heat, texture, and ingredients. Whether you prefer a mild and tangy mustard or a spicier variety, we’ve got you covered.

Choosing Mustard for Brats

Before we dive into the best mustards for brats, let’s discuss some key factors to consider when choosing the perfect condiment.

Type of Mustard

There are several types of mustard, each with its own distinct flavor and texture. When choosing mustard for brats, consider the following options:

  1. Yellow Mustard: Yellow mustard is a common variety often used on hot dogs and hamburgers. It pairs exceptionally well with brats.
  2. Honey Mustard: If you like the combination of sweet, tangy and spicy flavors, honey mustard is an excellent choice for brats.
  3. Whole Grain Mustard: With its thick, grainy texture and rich flavor, whole grain mustard adds a delightful touch to bratwurst.
  4. Brown Mustard: Brown mustard, made from brown mustard seeds, offers a spicier flavor and darker color.
  5. German Mustard: German mustard varieties are ideal for authentic German bratwurst sausages as they complement the flavor profile perfectly.

Spice Level

The heat of mustard depends on the type of mustard seeds used. White mustard seeds are milder and tangier, while black and brown seeds provide a spicier kick. If you prefer a mustard that adds heat to your brats, choose varieties made with darker seeds.


Mustard can vary in texture from thick and creamy to coarse and grainy. Consider your personal preference and how you plan to use the mustard. Grainy mustard works well as a finishing touch on brats, while creamier varieties are better for making creamy sauces.

Ingredient List

When purchasing mustard, check the ingredient list. Choose mustards with cleaner ingredient profiles and avoid those with excessive artificial additives and preservatives. Additionally, individuals on special diets should look for gluten-free, kosher, or paleo-friendly options. Checking calorie, fat, and sodium content is also beneficial for those who closely monitor their intake.

The 7 Best Brat Mustards of 2024

Now that we’ve discussed the key factors to consider when choosing mustard for brats, let’s explore the top seven mustards that are highly recommended to enhance your bratwurst experience:

1. Annie’s Horseradish Mustard

Annie’s Horseradish Mustard offers a mild yet unique flavor profile that makes it an excellent choice for family-friendly brat sandwiches. The combination of mustard seeds, vinegar and horseradish creates a condiment with a distinctive flavor. This organic and gluten-free mustard contains only 5 calories per serving, making it a healthy option for mustard lovers.

2. Wickedly Prime Mustard

For those looking for something new and exciting, Wickedly Prime Mustard offers a jalapeno-infused variety. With its medium heat and jalapeno chunks, this mustard adds an interesting twist to bratwurst sausages. It can be used as a brush-on marinade before grilling or frying and pairs well with sandwiches, pretzels and dressings.

3. Heinz Natural Yellow Mustard

Heinz Natural Yellow Mustard, also known as American Mustard, is an excellent choice for those who prefer a mild and tangy flavor without overwhelming heat. This versatile condiment complements not only brats, but also hamburgers, sandwiches and salad dressings. Made with all-natural ingredients, Heinz Yellow Mustard has zero calories per serving.

4. Inglehoffer Stone Ground Mustard

Inglehoffer Stone Ground Mustard is made by grinding brown mustard seeds in a stone mill, resulting in a tangy flavor and a coarse, grainy texture. This mustard offers a spicy kick and tang from the addition of white wine. Although it contains some additives such as sugar and natural flavors, it pairs exceptionally well with bratwurst.

5. Primal Kitchen Brown Mustard

Primal Kitchen Brown Mustard is made with a blend of brown mustard seeds, vinegar, and spices to create a flavorful and slightly spicy condiment. This gluten-free and paleo-friendly mustard is free of artificial ingredients and preservatives, making it a healthier option for brat lovers. Its smooth texture and bold flavor make it a great choice for adding a kick to your bratwurst.

6. French’s Classic Yellow Mustard

A staple in many homes, French’s Classic Yellow Mustard is known for its smooth texture and tangy flavor. This mustard is made from stone-ground mustard seeds, distilled vinegar and a blend of spices. It is a versatile condiment that complements a variety of dishes, including brats, burgers, and sandwiches.

7. Maille Dijon Mustard

Maille Dijon Mustard is a premium mustard that offers a sophisticated flavor profile to enhance your bratwurst experience. Made from finely ground mustard seeds, white wine and a blend of spices, this mustard has a smooth texture and a tangy yet slightly spicy flavor. It pairs well with brats and other gourmet sausages, adding a touch of elegance to your culinary creations.

Bottom line

In conclusion, choosing the best mustard for brats is a matter of personal preference. Whether you prefer a mild, tangy mustard or a spicier variety, there are plenty of options to enhance your bratwurst experience. Consider factors such as taste, heat, texture, and ingredients when making your selection. The seven mustards mentioned in this article-Annie’s Horseradish Mustard, Wickedly Prime Mustard, Heinz Natural Yellow Mustard, Inglehoffer Stone Ground Mustard, Primal Kitchen Brown Mustard, French’s Classic Yellow Mustard, and Maille Dijon Mustard-are highly recommended for their unique flavors and qualities. Experiment with different mustards to find the one that perfectly complements your bratwurst and enjoy the delightful combination of flavors.


tag for each question.