The best frying pan substitutes
Broiling is a popular cooking technique that allows food to cook quickly while giving it a nicely browned surface. While a broiling pan is commonly used for this method, there are times when you may not have access to one, or when things go wrong. In such cases, it’s helpful to know the best substitutes for a broiling pan. In this article, we will explore several alternatives that can be used to achieve similar results.
1. Wire rack grills
One of the best substitutes for a broiler pan is a roasting tray with a wire rack insert. When using a roasting tray, you need to place a wire rack on the inside of the pan to create a makeshift broiling pan. The wire rack helps separate the juices from the food and collect at the bottom of the pan. This prevents the juices from igniting at high temperatures.
If you don’t have a wire rack, you can purchase roasting trays that already have wire racks included. These racks are designed to improve air circulation during roasting, but when placed near the broiler, they function similarly to a grill pan. To prevent the possibility of a fire, you can cover the rack with a layer of foil and punch holes in it. This will allow the juices to drain while preventing the flames from reaching the food.
Recommended product: Farberware Nonstick Steel Roaster with Flat Rack
2. Cast Iron Griddle Pans
Cast iron griddle pans are another excellent option for broiling substitutes. Cast iron is known for its excellent thermal conductivity and can handle high temperatures with ease. Look for griddle pans with raised lines to replace a broiler lid or wire rack. The raised lines raise the food, allowing the juices to drain.
Griddle pans often come with a long handle and a grab handle for easy transport. These pans can easily withstand high temperatures, unlike some other materials that can scorch after each use.
Featured Product: Backcountry Cast Iron Square Grill Pan
3. Cast Iron Grill Plates
For larger cuts of meat or larger meals, cast iron griddles are a great alternative. These pans are flat and are typically used on a gas stove. Like griddle pans, they should have raised rims to allow juices to drain and prevent food from sticking to them.
What makes griddle pans special is their versatility. They can be used on both sides, with one side having the griddle lines and the other side being flat. This makes them ideal for a variety of cooking methods, including broiling.
Featured Product: LovoIn 1-Piece Cast Iron Griddle Plate
4. Baking sheets or trays
If you don’t have dedicated pans or trays, baking sheets or trays can work as makeshift broiling pans. While they may not have the same design as dedicated broiling pans, they can still produce satisfactory results.
To use a baking sheet or tray for broiling, place the food directly on the sheet or tray. Make sure the sheet or tray is large enough to hold the food without overcrowding. The lack of a wire rack or raised lines means that juices may not drain as effectively, so it’s important to monitor the food closely to prevent burning or excessive charring.
5. Disposable Aluminum Roasting Trays
Disposable aluminum roasting trays can be a convenient option when you need a quick and disposable replacement for a roasting pan. These trays are readily available at most grocery stores and are designed for single use.
To use a disposable aluminum roasting tray, place the food directly on the tray. The tray will catch the drippings and prevent them from igniting under the high broiling temperatures. While these trays may not be as durable as other options, they can be a convenient solution in a pinch.
Bottom Line
While a broiling pan is usually the best tool for broiling, there are several alternatives that can be used when a broiling pan is not available. Wire rack broiling pans, cast iron griddle pans and sheets, baking sheets or trays, and disposable aluminum broiling pans are all viable substitutes that can help achieve similar results.
When using these substitutes, it’s important to monitor the food closely to prevent burning or charring. Adjustments may be necessary to ensure even cooking and proper drainage of juices. By understanding these alternatives, you can continue to enjoy the delicious results of broiling even in the absence of a broiling pan.
FAQS
Can I use a grill tray instead of a broiler pan?
Yes, a grill tray can be used in place of a broiler pan. Simply place a wire rack inside the tray to help separate the juices from the food.
Can cast iron griddle pans be used for broiling?
Yes, cast iron griddle pans are an excellent substitute for broiling pans. The raised lines on the griddle pan help drain the juices from the food.
Can I use baking sheets or trays for broiling?
Yes, baking sheets or trays can be used as makeshift broiling pans. However, without a wire rack or raised lines, it’s important to monitor the food closely to prevent burning or excessive charring.
Are disposable aluminum pans effective for broiling?
Yes, disposable aluminum roasting trays can be used as a quick and convenient substitute for broiling pans. They catch drippings and prevent them from igniting at broiling temperatures.
Do these substitutes provide similar results to a broiler pan?
While these substitutes may not offer the exact design and functionality of a dedicated grill pan, they can still provide satisfactory results. Proper monitoring and adjustments may be necessary to ensure even cooking and drainage of juices.
Will I get the browning and cooking I want with these substitutes?
Yes, with proper techniques and monitoring, you can achieve desirable browning and cooking results with these substitutes. It’s important to follow the recommended cooking times and keep a close eye on the food to prevent burning or undercooking.