The 7 Best Bagel Toasters
Breakfast is often considered the most important meal of the day, and a popular choice for a quick and delicious breakfast option is a toasted bagel. Bagels, when toasted to perfection, offer a crisp texture and a warm center that pairs well with a variety of toppings. To achieve ideal toasting results, it’s important to invest in a reliable toaster specifically designed for bagels. In this article, we explore the seven best toasters for bagels, highlighting their features and benefits.
1. Chefman 2-slice pop-up toaster
The Chefman 2-Slice Pop-Up Toaster is our top pick for the best toaster for bagels. It features extra-wide slots that can accommodate thicker breads, making it perfect for toasting bagels. In addition, this toaster offers multiple browning settings so you can achieve the level of toasting you want. It also comes with a bagel setting specifically designed to toast bagels to perfection. With its sleek design and reliable performance, the Chefman toaster is an excellent choice for bagel lovers.
Pros:
- Extra wide slots fit bagels well
- Special bagel setting
- Easy cleanup with removable crumb tray
- Sleek stainless steel design
- High lift lever for easy removal
- Offers 7 color settings for custom toasting
Cons:
- The slots may not hold long slices of bread well.
- Toasting may not be even on both sides
2. Cuisinart Classic Metal Toaster
The Cuisinart Classic Metal Toaster is a budget-friendly option that doesn’t compromise on quality. This 4-slice toaster has separate settings for each side, so you can toast different items with different preferences at the same time. It offers six tint settings, so you can get the perfect level of toast for your bagels. The Cuisinart toaster also includes a bagel setting, as well as defrost, reheat and cancel options. Its wide slots and easy-to-use levers make it a convenient choice for bagel lovers.
Pros:
- 4-slice toaster for efficient toasting
- Bagel maker for perfect bagels
- Offers 6 color settings
- Available in different colors
- Wide slots for bagels
- Two control settings for versatility
Disadvantages
- Shade setting may need to be adjusted for optimal toasting results
3. Keemo Retro Small Toaster
For those who appreciate a touch of nostalgia, the Keemo Retro Small Toaster is an excellent choice. This compact toaster combines retro design with modern functionality. Despite its small size, it can accommodate bagels with its extra wide slots. The Keemo toaster offers a bagel setting, cancel and defrost options, and six color settings for customizable toasting. The high-lift lever makes it easy to retrieve toasted items, and the sliding crumb tray simplifies the cleaning process.
Pros:
- Compact and retro design
- Available in multiple colors
- Extra wide slots for bagels
- Bagel setting for optimal toasting
- Six color settings for customization
- High lift lever for easy retrieval
- Consistent toasting results
Cons:
- Bagels can get stuck in the slots
- Occasional uneven toasting
4. Holife Compact Bagel Toaster
The Holife Compact Bagel Toaster is a sleek and stylish option that offers efficient toasting performance. This 2-slice toaster features a stainless steel construction that adds a touch of elegance to any countertop. Despite its compact size, it has extra-wide slots that can accommodate bagels. The toaster includes an LCD display that shows the remaining toasting time and offers six color settings for personalized toasting. It also has a bagel setting, along with defrost and cancel options. The high-lift lever and removable crumb tray contribute to its user-friendly design.
Pros:
- Sleek and compact design
- Extra wide slots for bagels
- LCD display for remaining toasting time
- Bagel setting for optimal bagel toasting
- Six color settings for customization
- Removable crumb tray for easy cleaning
Disadvantages
- The slots may not hold long slices of bread well.
- Levers may not lift toasted items high enough for easy removal
5. Hamilton Beach Keep Warm 2-slice Toaster
The Hamilton Beach Keep Warm 2-Slice Toaster is an innovative option that keeps your bagels warm until you’re ready to enjoy them. This toaster features a unique Keep Warm setting that keeps toasted items warm for longer. It offers extra-wide slots to accommodate bagels of varying sizes and includes a bagel setting for optimal toasting. The Hamilton Beach Toaster also offers seven color settings to help you achieve your desired level of toasting. With its keep-warm feature and user-friendly design, this toaster is a convenient choice for bagel lovers.
Pros:
- Keep-warm setting to maintain toast temperature
- Extra wide slots for bagels
- Bagel setting for perfect bagels
- Seven color settings for customization
- Easy to use features and controls
- Slide out crumb tray for easy cleaning
Disadvantages
- The keep warm feature can overcook the bread if left on too long.
- Toaster may take longer to toast than other models
6. Breville 2-slice die-cast smart toaster
The Breville Die-Cast 2-slice Smart Toaster is a high-end option that offers advanced toasting technology. This toaster features intelligent one-touch auto lift and lower for consistent and precise toasting results. It has extra-wide slots to accommodate bagels and offers five color settings for customization. The Breville toaster includes a bagel and defrost setting, as well as a “lift and look” feature that allows you to check the progress of the toasting without interrupting the cycle. With its sleek design and impressive functionality, this toaster is a top choice for bagel lovers.
Pros:
- Intelligent one-touch automatic lowering and lifting
- Extra wide slots for bagels
- Five color settings for customization
- Bagel and defrost settings
- “Lift and look function for progress monitoring
- Easy cleaning with removable crumb tray
Disadvantages:
- The toaster may be more expensive compared to other models.
- Toasting may take longer than expected
7. Smeg Retro Style 2 slice toaster
The Smeg Retro Style 2 slice toaster combines vintage aesthetics with modern functionality. This toaster features a retro design that adds a charming touch to any kitchen decor. It has extra wide slots that can accommodate bagels and offers six color settings for personalized toasting. The Smeg toaster includes a bagel setting, defrost option and a handy removable stainless steel crumb tray. With its eye-catching design and reliable performance, this toaster is a great choice for bagel lovers who appreciate retro-inspired appliances.
Pros:
- Retro design with bright color options
- Extra-wide slots for bagels
- Six color settings for customization
- Bagel setting for optimal bagel topping
- Removable stainless steel crumb tray
- Consistent toasting results
Cons:
- Toaster can be bulky compared to other models
- Price may be higher compared to similar options
Bottom line
Investing in a high-quality toaster designed specifically for bagels can greatly enhance your breakfast experience. The Chefman 2-Slice Pop-Up Toaster stands out as our top pick with its extra-wide slots, bagel setting, and reliable performance. However, each toaster on this list offers unique features and benefits to suit different preferences and budgets. Whether you value compactness, advanced technology, budget-friendliness, or retro aesthetics, there’s a toaster on this list that will meet your needs. Choose the best bagel toaster that meets your needs and enjoy perfectly toasted bagels every morning.
FAQS
What makes a toaster suitable for toasting bagels?
A toaster suitable for toasting bagels should have extra wide slots to accommodate the thicker bread. It should also have a bagel setting that evenly toasts the cut side of the bagel while gently warming the outside.
Can I use a regular toaster to toast bagels?
While a regular toaster can toast bagels to some extent, a toaster specifically designed for bagels will provide better results. Regular toasters may not have slots wide enough to fit bagels properly, resulting in uneven toasting or difficulty fitting the bagel in.
Are the toasters on this list good for toasting other types of bread?
Yes, the toasters on this list are versatile and can toast different types of bread, including sliced bread, artisan bread, English muffins, and more. They offer settings and features that allow you to achieve the desired level of toasting for different types of bread.
Can these toasters take long slices of bread?
While most of the toasters on this list have extra-wide slots that can accommodate bagels, they may not be suitable for extra-long slices of bread. If you frequently toast longer slices of bread, it is recommended that you check the dimensions of the toaster slots before making a purchase.
Are these toasters easy to clean?
Yes, the toasters mentioned in this article are designed to be easy to clean. They typically have removable crumb trays that are easy to empty and clean. Some models also have a high-lift lever that allows you to lift the toasted items higher for easy removal and cleaning of the toaster’s interior.
Do these toasters have different color settings?
Yes, all of the toasters on this list offer multiple tint settings so you can adjust the level of toasting to your liking. Whether you prefer a lightly toasted bagel or a darker, crispier texture, these toasters offer options to achieve your desired level of browning.