The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Perfect Cookie Cutters for Sandwiches

The best cookie cutters for sandwiches

Sandwiches are a popular meal option that evokes nostalgia and simplicity. They can be customized in many ways, including cutting them into fun shapes and sizes. Using cookie cutters for sandwiches adds an element of creativity and fun, especially for children. However, choosing the right cookie cutter is important to ensure a smooth cut without sticking or tearing the sandwich. In this article, we will guide you through choosing the best cookie cutters for sandwiches and share our top picks.

Choosing the Perfect Sandwich Cookie Cutters

There are several factors to consider when choosing the right cookie cutters for sandwiches. Here are some important things to consider:

1. Size:

When choosing a cookie cutter, it is important to consider its size in relation to your bread. While you can use any cookie cutter, it is ideal to choose one that closely matches the size of your bread. This will prevent excessive waste and ensure that the cutter effectively cuts through the sandwich.

2. Material:

Choose a cookie cutter made of solid material, preferably one that stands tall. This will ensure a smooth cut through the bread without breaking it. Stainless steel cutters are a popular choice for their durability and ease of cleaning.

3. Cleaning:

Consider the cleaning process when choosing cutters. Dishwasher safe cutters or those that can be easily wiped clean without worrying about getting stuck in small crevices are recommended. This will save time and effort in maintaining the cutters.

4. Variety:

While a single shape may suffice, a variety of shapes adds more fun to the sandwich-making experience. Look for package options that offer multiple shapes to keep things exciting.

Top Picks for Sandwich Cutters

After extensive research and consideration, we narrowed down the options and compiled a list of the best cookie cutters for sandwiches. Here are our top picks:

1. Tiblue Sandwich Cutters, 24-Piece Set

– Multiple shapes and sizes
– Made of stainless steel with a PP handle
– 24 piece set
– Smooth cut and easy to clean
– Also suitable for fruits and vegetables

2. Star Pack Kids Sandwich Cutters, Set of 4

– Fun and colorful shapes
– Made of plastic
– Set of 4 shapes: jigsaw, heart, dinosaur and butterfly
– Easy to clean
– Suitable for peanut butter and jelly, lunch meat and other fillings

3. Kids Cookie Cutters, Set of 6

– Multiple shapes for kids
– Made of stainless steel
– 6-piece set
– Versatile cutter for sandwiches, cookies and cakes
– Compact and easy to clean

4. KAISHANE 23 piece sandwich cutter set

– Fun and colorful shapes
– 23-piece set includes sandwich, vegetable and fruit cutters
– Made of stainless steel with plastic frame
– Easy to clean design
– Works for different styles and seasons

Excess Bread Ideas

When you use cookie cutters to make sandwiches, you inevitably end up with extra bread. Instead of wasting it, here are some creative ways to repurpose the leftover bread:

  • Turn leftover bread into homemade croutons.
  • Freeze the extra bread and save it for special recipes like Thanksgiving stuffing.
  • Make your own breadcrumbs by grinding your leftover bread.
  • Crumble leftover bread and add it to soups instead of crackers.
  • Sprinkle bread with cinnamon and sugar, then bake for a sweet treat.
  • Use the extra bread as a crust for quiches or pies.
  • Incorporate it into bread pudding or other bread-based desserts.

Use these ideas to minimize waste and get the most out of every slice of bread.


Cookie cutters can transform ordinary sandwiches into delicious and visually appealing treats. When choosing sandwich cutters, consider size, material, cleaning process and variety of shapes. Our top picks, including the Tiblue Sandwich Cutters, Star Pack Kids Sandwich Cutter, Cookie Cutter for Kids, and KAISHANE 23-Piece Sandwich Cutters, offer a range of options to suit your preferences. Plus, reusing excess bread from the cutting process allows you to minimize waste and explore creative culinary possibilities. Enjoy the process of making sandwiches with these cutters and bring joy to your meals.


What are the benefits of using cookie cutters for sandwiches?

Cookie cutters allow you to add creativity and fun to your sandwiches. They help transform ordinary sandwiches into visually appealing shapes, making mealtime more exciting for both kids and adults.

Can I use any cookie cutter to make sandwiches?

While you can technically use any cookie cutter for sandwiches, it’s recommended that you choose cutters specifically designed for sandwich cutting. Sandwich cutters are usually the ideal size and shape to prevent excessive waste and ensure a smooth cutting experience.

What should I consider when choosing a sandwich cookie cutter?

When choosing a sandwich cookie cutter, consider factors such as size, material, cleaning method and variety. Choose a cutter that closely matches the size of your bread, is made of a sturdy material such as stainless steel, is easy to clean (preferably dishwasher safe), and offers a variety of shapes for added versatility.

Are stainless steel cookie cutters better than plastic?

Stainless steel cookie cutters are generally preferred over plastic cookie cutters due to their durability, ease of cleaning, and ability to cut smoothly without crushing the bread. However, plastic cookie cutters may still be suitable for occasional use and are often more affordable.

What can I do with the leftover bread from using cookie cutters?

Instead of wasting the extra bread, you can use it in a variety of ways. Some ideas include making homemade croutons, freezing it for future use in recipes like Thanksgiving stuffing, making breadcrumbs, adding it to soups as a substitute for crackers, baking it with cinnamon and sugar for a sweet treat, using it as a crust for quiches or pies, or incorporating it into bread pudding or desserts.

Can I use sandwich cutters for anything other than sandwiches?

Yes, sandwich cutters can be used for more than just sandwiches. They can also be used to cut fruit, vegetables, cookies, biscuits and other soft foods. This versatility makes them a handy tool to have in the kitchen for a variety of culinary creations.