The Ultimate Guide to the 7 Best Substitutes For Coconut Butter

The 7 Best Coconut Butter Substitutes

Coconut butter is a popular ingredient known for its smooth and creamy texture, delicious taste, and nutritional benefits. However, if you are looking for alternatives to coconut butter, whether due to dietary preferences, availability, or cost, there are several options that can provide a similar consistency and health benefits. In this article, we will explore the seven best coconut butter substitutes.

Peanut Butter

Peanut butter is an excellent substitute for coconut butter due to its similar texture and nutritional value. It is readily available in most supermarkets and is easy to make at home. To make peanut butter, simply process roasted peanuts in a food processor until they form a smooth paste. You can improve the flavor and consistency by adding salt, neutral-flavored oil, or sweeteners such as sugar or honey. Peanut butter can be used in many recipes that call for coconut butter.

Almond Butter

Almond butter is another versatile substitute that shares some flavor undertones with coconut butter. It has a creamy texture and is packed with healthy nutrients. Like peanut butter, almond butter can be found in stores or made at home by grinding roasted almonds into a smooth paste. For added flavor, you can incorporate coarsely shredded coconut flesh or almond nuts. Almond butter can be used in a variety of recipes, including pancakes, cookies, and more.

Cashew Butter

Cashew butter is a creamy, thick paste, similar in consistency to coconut butter. It can be purchased at the grocery store or made at home by lightly toasting cashews until they are whitish brown, then blending them until they are thick and creamy. Salt can be added as needed to enhance the flavor. Cashew butter is a great substitute for coconut butter and has a similar texture and flavor.

Vegan butter/regular butter

For those who prefer non-nut based substitutes, both vegan butter and regular butter can be used as alternatives to coconut butter. While the flavor may be slightly different, they have a similar consistency and can be used interchangeably in most recipes. Vegan butter is suitable for those with dietary restrictions and offers a lighter flavor compared to coconut butter. Regular butter can be used in various recipes by garnishing or infusing it with shredded coconut meat to mimic the coconut flavor.


Tahini is a versatile and delicious spread that can be used as a close substitute for coconut butter. It offers a thick and creamy texture and can add a unique flavor profile to your dishes. Tahini is made from toasted sesame seeds, which can be processed until they are a light white-golden color. Additional oils or flavors can be added to create a more holistic tahini blend. This ingredient can be used in a variety of recipes, including wraps, salads and savory dishes.


While it may seem unconventional, yogurt can be a great substitute for coconut butter, especially when flavored with cream, salt, sugar, or honey. Yogurt acts as a blank canvas that can be customized with different ingredients. Greek yogurt, when combined with a bit of sugar and shredded coconut flesh, closely resembles the taste and texture of coconut butter. The use of high quality starter cultures in the production of yogurt ensures a flavorful and non-sour yogurt. Yogurt can be a healthy and versatile substitute for coconut butter in many recipes.

Melon Seeds

Melon seeds, like other nut butters, can serve as an excellent substitute for coconut butter. They can be used as is or processed into a butter-like consistency. Melon seeds can be purchased pre-packaged or sun-dried at home for a few days or in a dehydrator to achieve a crunchy texture. To make melon seed butter, simply process the dried seeds into a smooth paste. Adding a neutral oil may help to further smooth the mixture. Melon seeds can be used as a topping or incorporated into a variety of recipes.


When it comes to replacing coconut butter, there are several options that offer similar consistency, taste, and nutritional benefits. Peanut butter, almond butter, and cashew butter are excellent alternatives that offer comparable textures and flavors. Vegan butter or regular butter can be used as a non-nut-based substitute. Tahini offers a unique flavor profile, while yogurt is a versatile option that can be customized to mimic the taste and texture of coconut butter. Melon seeds, whether used as is or processed into a butter-like consistency, can also serve as a great substitute. Explore these substitutes based on your preferences and dietary needs to enjoy the benefits of coconut butter in alternative forms.


Can I use any nut butter instead of coconut butter?

Yes, nut butters like peanut butter, almond butter, and cashew butter can be excellent alternatives to coconut butter. They offer similar textures and flavors that work well in various recipes.

Are these substitutes as nutritious as coconut butter?

While the nutritional composition may vary slightly, nut butters and other substitutes generally offer their own set of health benefits. They are rich in healthy fats, protein, and essential nutrients, making them a valuable part of a balanced diet.

Can I make these substitutes at home?

Yes, many of these substitutes can be easily made at home using a food processor or blender. By processing the respective nuts, seeds, or ingredients, you can create homemade versions of peanut butter, almond butter, cashew butter, tahini, and more.

How do I choose the right substitute for my recipe?

Choosing a substitute depends on your personal preferences, dietary restrictions, and desired flavor profile. Consider the texture, taste, and nutritional benefits of each substitute to find the one that best complements your recipe.

Can I use these alternatives in baking and cooking?

Absolutely! These substitutes can be used in a variety of baking and cooking recipes that call for coconut butter. Whether you’re making cookies, cakes, sauces or spreads, these alternatives can provide similar results with their creamy texture and rich flavor.

Where can I find these replacements?

Most supermarkets carry a wide variety of nut butters, including peanut butter, almond butter, and cashew butter. You can also find tahini and yogurt at grocery stores or specialty food stores. Alternatively, you can make these substitutes at home using readily available ingredients.