Unveiling the Top 9 Butter Churners of 2021: The Ultimate Guide

Churning butter has a long history as a labor-intensive process that required hours of manual labor. However, with the advent of better butter churners and technological advancements, making butter at home has become much easier and more convenient. In this article, we will explore the 9 best butter churners of 2021 and provide you with an ultimate guide to help you choose the right one for your needs.

Electric vs. Manual (Wooden) Butter Churners

When choosing a butter churn, one of the first decisions you’ll have to make is whether to go with an electric or manual (wooden) churn. Electric churners offer convenience and consistency in the butter making process. They eliminate the need for manual labor and produce a more homogeneous and consistent butter. They are particularly suitable for those who prefer a hassle-free approach to butter making.
On the other hand, manual or wooden butter churners offer a nostalgic and hands-on experience. They allow for more control over the churning process and are often favored by those who appreciate the traditional art of butter making. Hand churners, especially those made of wood, are known to produce butter with a unique flavor and texture. They work at a slower pace, allowing you to be more involved in the process.

Churn size

The size of the churn is another important factor to consider. Most modern butter churners have a capacity of 1 liter of cream, which typically yields about 350-400 grams of butter. This should be sufficient for the needs of most households. However, if you require larger quantities of butter or prefer to make butter in larger batches, you may want to consider either an electric churn or a larger manual churn.
While traditional large, farm-inspired plunger churners are available, they can be clunky, messy, and time-consuming. If you need to make more butter, it is often more practical to reuse a typical 1 liter churn. These smaller churners can make butter in minutes, especially when using electric churners or mixers.

Churn Material

The material of the churner is another important aspect to consider. There are several types of churners available, but the most recommended options for home use are glass jar churners and larger wooden churners.
Glass jar churners are easy to clean and can be sanitized after each use, making them a hygienic choice. They are suitable for home users who value cleanliness and convenience. Wooden churners, while more difficult to clean, are often preferred by professional butter makers who are familiar with the intricacies of the churning process. Wooden churns can impart a slightly different flavor to the butter, adding to its unique appeal.
It is advisable to avoid cheap plastic churners as they are prone to damage and may not provide the durability and stability required for effective butter churning. Instead, it is best to opt for churners made of high quality wood or glass.

Additional Accessories

When choosing a butter churn, it is beneficial to consider the availability of additional accessories that can enhance your butter churning experience. Some churners come with paddles specifically designed to lift, squeeze and shape the butter. These paddles facilitate the butter separation process and ensure a smooth and consistent texture.
Other accessories that may be included with butter churners are spare parts, recipe books, and special butter cloths for cleaning the butter mixture. These additional tools can make the butter churning process more convenient and enjoyable.

9 Best Butter Churners of 2021

  1. Kilner Small Manual Butter Churn: This churner is designed for everyday use and comes with gears and handles for easy operation. It has a 1 liter capacity and produces butter in minutes.
  2. Buttermeister Butter Churn: This electric churn is portable and works on any 110V outlet. It features a tinted glass jar design that allows you to watch the churning process.
  3. The Tamarack Hand Butter Churn: This traditional churn features a 1-gallon jar shape and maple wood paddles. Its mechanical design makes churning butter easy and efficient.
  4. Tescoma Della Casa Butter Churn: This churn uses a plunger design and is made of high-quality, food-safe plastic. It is lightweight, durable and easy to clean.
  5. Homeplace Drill Powered Butter Churn: This wet ingredient mixer provides an easy way to make butter without exerting excessive energy. It comes with a large square bowl for efficient churning.
  6. Paderno World Cuisine fresh butter churn: This hand-crank churn offers a compact design and is known for its simplicity. It produces fresh butter with minimal effort.
  7. Chef’n Buttercup Butter Maker: This churner features a top mesh to separate buttermilk and butter for a cleaner, smoother end product.
  8. Kilner Butter Churn Set: This set includes a 1-liter glass jar churner, wooden paddles, and a recipe booklet. It provides a comprehensive package for those beginning their butter churning journey.
  9. KitchenAid Stand Mixer Butter Churn Attachment: This attachment turns your KitchenAid stand mixer into a butter churner. It offers convenience and versatility, allowing you to use your existing kitchen equipment.


In conclusion, choosing the right butter churn can greatly enhance your at-home butter making experience. Whether you choose an electric churner for convenience or a manual wooden churner for a traditional touch, the key is to find a churner that meets your needs and preferences. Consider factors such as churn size, material, and additional accessories to ensure a smooth and enjoyable butter-making process. With the 9 Best Butter Churners of 2021 as your guide, you can embark on a journey to create delicious homemade butter that will delight your taste buds.


What is a butter churner?

A butter churner is a device used to stir cream or milk to separate the butterfat from the liquid. It accelerates the natural process of butter formation by creating a constant agitation.

Why should I consider churning my own butter?

Churning your own butter gives you control over the ingredients and the process. It gives you the opportunity to create fresh, homemade butter with a unique flavor and texture. It can also be a fun and rewarding culinary experience.

Are electric churns better than hand churns?

Electric churners offer convenience and consistency, producing a more uniform butter. They are ideal for those who prefer a hands-off approach. Manual churners, on the other hand, offer a nostalgic and hands-on experience, allowing for greater control and potentially yielding butter with a distinct flavor. The choice between electric and manual churners ultimately comes down to personal preference.

What factors should I consider when choosing a butter churn?

Some important factors to consider are the size of the churn, the material, and any additional accessories. The size should fit your butter-making needs, while the material should be of high quality and match your preferences (such as glass or wood). Additional accessories, such as paddles or recipe books, can enhance your butter-making experience.

How long does it take to churn butter?

The time it takes to churn butter can vary depending on the churn and the amount of cream or milk used. In general, it can take anywhere from a few minutes to an hour. Electric churners usually take less time than manual churners.

Can I make butter without a churner?

While a butter churn simplifies the process, it is possible to churn butter without one. Traditional methods include using a glass jar or a stand mixer with a special attachment. However, these methods may require more effort and time than using a dedicated butter churn.