Color Your Creations: The Top 5 Food Colorings for Royal Icing in 2024

5 Best Food Coloring for Royal Icing of 2024

Royal icing is a versatile and delicious option for adding stunning colors to cakes and other baked goods. However, when it comes to choosing the right food coloring for royal icing, it’s important to consider the consistency and pigmentation of the color. In this article, we will explore the five best food colors for royal icing in 2023.

1. Wilton Gel-Based Icing Colors

Wilton Gel-Based Icing Colors are a top choice for coloring royal icing without changing its consistency. This 12-pack includes a wide range of colors including green, purple, pink, brown, yellow, black, red, royal blue, golden yellow, burgundy, teal and copper. Each color is packaged in a 0.5-ounce jar with an easy-open lid. The gel-based formula provides highly pigmented shades, requiring only a small amount of color to achieve rich hues. These food colors are certified Kosher and made in the USA, making them suitable for both novice and expert bakers.

2. Bakerpan Food Coloring Gel

The Bakerpan Food Coloring Gel Kit offers deep and vibrant colors for royal icing without diluting it. With seven colors including Super Red, Royal Blue, Lemon Yellow, Leaf Green, Orange, Purple and Black, this kit offers a variety of options to create your desired hues. The professional strength formula provides intense color with minimal product usage. The 1-ounce tubs are long-lasting, and the gel-based colors maintain the consistency of the frosting. Compared to liquid food coloring, these gel-based colors offer highly pigmented and vibrant shades. They are suitable for a variety of baking projects and allow for easy color mixing.

3. Chefmaster Food Color Gel

The Chefmaster Food Coloring Gel set includes liquid gel colors that are highly concentrated and ideal for cake decorating, including royal icing. These colors disperse instantly when added to icing, and the flip-top squeeze bottles allow for precise control and easy measurement. Available in a 12-pack of primary or secondary colors, these food colors are formulated for use with whipped topping, buttercream frosting, cake batter, cookie dough, fondant and royal icing. Made in the USA with quality ingredients, they are also certified Kosher.

4. AmeriColor Soft Gel Coloring Paste

AmeriColor Soft Gel Coloring Paste offers superior tinting strength and vibrant colors for royal icing. The gel paste colors will not separate, crack or harden the frosting while providing rich and vibrant colors that are often difficult to achieve with liquid food colors. This Junior Kit includes red, dark pink, purple, sky blue, lemon yellow, leaf green, orange and chocolate brown. The gel-cream colors disperse instantly, so only a tiny amount is needed for the desired color. The convenient squeeze bottles with flip-top lids make it easy to control the amount of color used. Mixing different colors allows you to create unique shades, and the gel-paste colors maintain the consistency of the frosting.

5. McCormick Assorted Food Colors

The McCormick Assorted Food Colors kit is a versatile way to add bright colors to royal icing. This kit includes red, yellow, green and blue colors that can be mixed to create different shades and tones. The drop control vials make it easy to measure and repeat colors consistently. These food colors can be used not only for royal icing and baked goods, but also for arts and crafts projects. They are easy to use and provide a long-lasting supply for baking and frosting projects.
In conclusion, when it comes to coloring royal icing, it is important to choose a food coloring option that will maintain the consistency of the icing while providing vibrant and rich colors. The Wilton Gel-Based Icing Colors, Bakerpan Food Coloring Gel, Chefmaster Food Coloring Gel, AmeriColor Soft Gel Coloring Paste, and McCormick Assorted Food Colors are five excellent choices for achieving beautiful and colorful royal icing in 2024.


Which food coloring is best for royal icing?

The best food color for royal icing is a soft gel food color. Gel-based food colors maintain the consistency of the icing and offer highly pigmented shades with only a small amount of coloring.

Why should I choose gel food colors for royal icing?

Gel-based food colors are preferred for royal icing because they do not change the consistency of the icing. They provide vibrant and rich colors, and a little goes a long way.

Can I mix different food colors to create unique colors?

Yes, you can mix different food colors to create custom shades for your Royal Icing. Gel-based food colors are especially good for mixing because they blend well and maintain the consistency you want.

Are these food colors suitable for beginners?

Yes, the recommended food colors are suitable for both novice and expert bakers. They are easy to work with and provide consistent results, allowing beginners to achieve professional-looking royal icing.

How long will these food colors last?

The shelf life of food colors varies depending on the application. However, because gel food colors are highly pigmented, only a small amount is typically needed, making them last longer than liquid food colors.

Can I use these food colors for anything other than royal icing?

Absolutely! These food colors can be used for a variety of baking projects, including coloring cake batter, frosting, cookies, and more. They can also be used for arts and crafts projects.