Perfectly Shaped Biscuits: Discover the 5 Best Biscuit Cutter Substitutes

5 Best Cookie Cutter Replacements

Cookies are a delicious treat that can be easily made at home, filling the air with the comforting aroma of a bakery. While making cookies is a straightforward process, one common tool that is often required is a cookie cutter. However, not everyone has a cookie cutter in their kitchen. The good news is that there are several common kitchen tools that can be used as excellent substitutes. In this article, we will explore the five best cookie cutter substitutes and how to use them effectively to achieve perfectly shaped cookies every time.

1. Upside-down cup or glass

One of the simplest and most accessible cookie cutter replacements is an upside-down cup or glass. Most households have cups and glasses of various sizes, making them convenient options for cutting cookies. To use an upside-down cup or glass as a replacement, simply turn it upside down and press it into the dough. To prevent the dough from sticking to the inside and edges, it is recommended to dip the glass in flour before use. While a glass with a thin rim is ideal for cutting through the dough, a regular glass or cup can also be used effectively. It is important to note, however, that if the dough gets stuck inside, it can be a bit of a challenge to remove it without distorting the shape of the cookie.

2. Commercial product tins and cans

Another excellent substitute for a cookie cutter is a commercial product can, such as those used for tuna or processed fruit. These cans and cans work well as cookie cutters and offer versatility in size and shape. To use them as a replacement, first remove both ends of the can with a can opener. Then wash the can to remove any food residue or odor and wipe it dry. The thin metal of these cans allows for even cutting through the dough, similar to using a real cookie cutter. While it is not necessary to remove both ends of the can, doing so will make it easier to remove the dough if it gets stuck. By pushing the dough out the other end, any distortion can be easily corrected.

3. Cookie cutter

A cookie cutter can be an excellent alternative to a cookie cutter. While a cookie cutter typically comes in a simple round shape, a cookie cutter offers a variety of fun shapes and sizes. Although cookie cutters often have intricate details that can be obscured as the cookies rise during baking, they can still be used effectively. When using a cookie cutter as a substitute, make sure it has high sides to cut through the cookie dough without compromising its shape. Cookie cutters come in a variety of shapes and patterns, including squares, rectangles, flowers, hearts, stars, trees, and dinosaurs. If a round shape is desired, a cookie cutter with a plain and bold shape can be used for similar results.

4. Kitchen Knife

A kitchen knife can be a versatile tool not only for cutting meats, fruits and vegetables, but also for shaping cookie dough. While using a kitchen knife may not provide the same level of uniformity as a cookie cutter or the previously mentioned substitutes, it does offer the opportunity to be creative with cookie shapes. After rolling out the dough, it can be cut into several pieces and the edge of the knife can be used to give each piece the desired shape. Alternatively, a butter knife can be used for those who are more comfortable with its handling or when involving children in the cookie-making process.

5. Pizza Cutter

For those who prefer a safer and more controlled option, a pizza cutter may be a suitable substitute for a cookie cutter. Pizza cutters come in a variety of sizes, allowing for flexibility in shaping the cookie dough. Traditional round shapes are easily achieved with a pizza cutter, but it is also possible to create other popular shapes such as squares, rectangles, triangles or diamonds. By using a pizza cutter, you can achieve precise and consistent cuts that result in well-formed cookies.
In conclusion, while a cookie cutter is a specialized tool for creating perfectly round cookies, there are several viable substitutes that can be used in its absence. Upside-down cups or glasses, commercial jars and cans, cookie cutters, kitchen knives, and pizza cutters are all effective alternatives. Whether it’s using everyday kitchen items or repurposing tools meant for other culinary tasks, these substitutes allow home cooks to shape cookies without compromising taste or aesthetics. By using these substitutes and following proper techniques, anyone can enjoy homemade cookies with ease and satisfaction.


Can I use a regular glass or cup to replace the cookie cutter?

Yes, an ordinary glass or cup can be used to replace a cookie cutter. Just be sure to turn it upside down and dip it in flour to prevent the dough from sticking.

How do I use a commercial jar or can as a cookie cutter replacement?

To use a commercial product tin or can, remove both ends of the can with a can opener. Wash the can to remove any food residue or odor, then wipe dry. Press the can into the dough to cut out the cookies.

Are cookie cutters a good alternative to cookie cutters?

Yes, cookie cutters can be an excellent substitute for cookie cutters. They come in a variety of shapes and sizes so you can get creative with your cookie shapes.

Can I use a kitchen knife to cut cookie dough?

Yes, a kitchen knife can be used to shape cookie dough. After rolling out the dough, you can cut it into pieces and use the edge of the knife to give each piece the shape you want.

Can a pizza cutter replace a cookie cutter?

Absolutely! A pizza cutter can be a great replacement for a cookie cutter. It allows for precise and consistent cuts, making it easy to get the cookie dough into the desired shape.

How important is it to dip the jar or cup in flour when using it as a cookie cutter replacement?

Dipping the glass or cup in flour is critical when using it as a cookie cutter replacement. It will help prevent the dough from sticking to the glass or cup, making for clean and easy cuts.