Top 7 Organic Peanut Butter Brands of 2024: A Nutty Delight

7 Best Organic Peanut Butter Brands of 2024

Peanut butter is a beloved staple in North America, often evoking nostalgic memories of childhood meals. Whether you prefer it smooth or crunchy, thick or thin, opting for organic peanut butter is a wise choice. Organic peanut butter is free of toxic chemicals, making it a healthier option. In this article, we will explore the seven best organic peanut butter brands of 2024, highlighting their defining characteristics to help you choose the one that suits your preferences.

1. Spread The Love NAKED Organic Peanut Butter

Spread The Love is a family-owned natural food company that lives up to its name. Their peanut butter is called “naked” because it contains only dry-roasted organic peanuts, with no additives or thickeners. This brand is known for its consistent quality because it is made in small batches to minimize food processing. The texture of Spread The Love NAKED Organic Peanut Butter is thin and naturally oily, offering a rich and creamy flavor. It is perfect for a variety of uses, such as dipping fruit, creating sauces, or adding to smoothies.
Key features:

  • Made with dry-roasted organic peanuts
  • No added sugars, oils or unnecessary ingredients
  • Available in a variety of sizes, from single servings to 15-pound pails

Biggest drawback: The lack of additives or thickeners results in a thinner consistency compared to other options on this list.

2. Santa Cruz Organic, Dark Roasted Peanut Butter, Creamy

Santa Cruz is a remarkable peanut butter manufacturer that has turned this commodity into a craft specialty. Their dark roasted creamy peanut butter has a unique flavor profile. It is made with no artificial ingredients or hydrogenated oils, just peanuts. The creamy texture of this peanut butter is thin but not overly runny, making it easy to mix and spread. It is packaged in a glass jar to ensure premium taste and long-term quality.
Key features:

  • No artificial ingredients or hydrogenated oils
  • Dark roasted for a deep, nutty, toasted flavor
  • Packaged in a glass jar for premium taste and quality

Major drawback: Glass jar packaging may be more susceptible to damage during transit than plastic containers.

3. Kirkland Organic Creamy Peanut Butter U.S. Valencia Peanuts

Kirkland Organic Creamy Peanut Butter is made with dry-roasted Valencia peanuts. Valencia peanuts are known for their natural sweetness and deliciousness. They are also grown in an environment that is too dry for aflatoxin, a potentially dangerous mold, to grow. This peanut butter has a very smooth, thin and creamy texture when well blended. A small amount of sea salt is added to enhance the flavor of the peanuts.
Key Features:

  • Made with Valencia peanuts, free from potentially hazardous fungi
  • Contains a small amount of sea salt to enhance flavor
  • Easy to spread and silky smooth

Biggest drawback: Some people may find the thinness of this peanut butter, along with other natural peanut butters, unusual if they are accustomed to brands that contain added oils and sugars.

4. Adams Organic Creamy Peanut Butter

Adams offers a variety of natural peanut butters, including two organic options: creamy and crunchy. Their organic peanut butters have a clean ingredient list, consisting only of roasted peanuts and a touch of salt for flavor. While not a no-stir variety, Adams peanut butter holds together well after stirring. The texture of this peanut butter is not too thin and not too thick, with a slightly grainy consistency.
Key features:

  • Dedicated exclusively to high quality, all natural peanut butter.
  • No added sugar, trans fats, artificial colors or preservatives
  • Packaged in a glass jar for quality storage

Biggest drawback: Adams Organic Peanut Butter is available in a maximum jar size of 16 ounces, which may not be enough for those who consume peanut butter on a regular basis.

5. Organic peanut butter from Yumbutter

Yumbutter specializes in handcrafted nut and seed butters for active individuals seeking protein and nutrient-rich options. Yumbutter’s organic peanut butter has a thick and creamy texture. It contains organic, fair trade palm oil and organic coconut sugar to enhance flavor and texture without compromising on quality ingredients or sustainability. This peanut butter is made in a certified gluten-free facility.
Key Features:

  • Part of the “Buy One, Help Nourish a Child” program to help children in need
  • Contains organic fair trade palm oil and organic coconut sugar
  • Made in a certified gluten-free facility

Biggest drawback: Although organic, the inclusion of palm oil adds hydrogenated oil to the peanut butter.

6. Trader Joe’s Creamy No Salt Organic Peanut Butter

Trader Joe’s Creamy No Salt Organic Peanut Butter is an excellent option for those who prefer a peanut butter with no added salt. Made with organic Valencia peanuts, this peanut butter has a thin and soupy consistency. It contains no added salt or other ingredients, allowing the natural flavor of the peanuts to shine through. Trader Joe’s Peanut Butter is perfect for those who are watching their sodium intake or who prefer to add their own seasonings to their recipes.
Key Features:

  • Made with organic Valencia peanuts
  • No added salt or other ingredients
  • Suitable for people watching their sodium intake

Biggest drawback: The thin and soupy consistency of this peanut butter may not appeal to those who prefer a thicker texture.

7. Once Again Organic, Crunchy Peanut Butter – Salt Free, Unsweetened

Once Again Organic offers a salt-free and unsweetened crunchy peanut butter option perfect for those who enjoy the natural taste and texture of peanuts. Made with organic dry-roasted peanuts, this peanut butter has a thick and creamy consistency. It does not require stirring, making it convenient for immediate use. The absence of salt and added sugar allows the true flavor of the peanuts to shine through.
Key features:

  • Made with organic dry roasted peanuts
  • Salt-free and unsweetened
  • No stirring required

Major drawback: The lack of salt may result in a less pronounced flavor compared to salted varieties.
In conclusion, when choosing organic peanut butter, it is important to consider factors such as ingredients, texture, and personal preference. Spread The Love NAKED Organic Peanut Butter, Santa Cruz Organic Dark Roasted Peanut Butter, Kirkland Organic Creamy Peanut Butter, Adams Organic Creamy Peanut Butter, Yumbutter Organic Peanut Butter, Trader Joe’s Creamy No Salt Organic Peanut Butter, and Once Again Organic Crunchy Peanut Butter are all excellent options that offer unique characteristics to suit different tastes and needs. By choosing one of these top organic peanut butter brands, you can enjoy a healthier and more flavorful option for your favorite peanut butter recipes.


Why should I choose organic peanut butter?

Choosing organic peanut butter ensures that it is free from toxic chemicals such as pesticides and chemical fertilizers, making it a healthier choice for you and the environment.

Is organic peanut butter more expensive?

Yes, organic peanut butters tend to have a higher price tag compared to non-organic options. This is because organic peanuts are more expensive to grow and the additional cost is passed on to the consumer.

Does organic peanut butter taste different than regular peanut butter?

Organic peanut butter may taste slightly different from regular peanut butter. It often has a more natural and nutty flavor due to the lack of artificial ingredients and additives.

Can organic peanut butter be used for cooking and baking?

Absolutely! Organic peanut butter is versatile and can be used in a variety of recipes, from sauces and dressings to cookies and cakes. Its creamy texture and rich flavor make it a delicious addition to many culinary creations.

Will organic peanut butter have a different texture than non-organic peanut butter?

The texture of organic peanut butter can vary depending on the brand and processing methods. Some organic peanut butters may have a thinner consistency, while others may be thicker and creamier. It’s best to read product descriptions or reviews to get an idea of the texture before you buy.

Are there any risks associated with eating organic peanut butter?

When consumed in moderation, organic peanut butter is generally safe for most people. However, it’s important to be aware of any potential allergies or sensitivities to peanuts. In addition, some brands of organic peanut butter may contain traces of other nuts, so people with nut allergies should exercise caution and read labels carefully.